The Evidence on Teaching

Time spent in outdoor activities in relation to myopia prevention and control - a meta-analysis and systematic review

Xiong S, Sankaridurg P, Naduvilath T, Zang J, Zou H, Zhu J, Lv M, He X, Xu X · 2017

grade Cmeta-analysisindependentunreplicated
Sample
25 articles pooled from 51 with relevant data; 23 of 25 involved children
Population
Mostly school-aged children across East Asia, Australia, Europe and North America
Design
Pools clinical trials, longitudinal cohorts and cross-sectional studies together, so the aggregate inherits the confounding of the observational majority - graded C on that basis. Reports clinical-trial and observational strata separately, which is what makes it usable. Dose-response analysis performed.
Key findings
Protective effect on INCIDENT myopia in clinical trials (RR 0.536, 95% CI 0.338-0.850) and in longitudinal cohorts (RR 0.574, 95% CI 0.395-0.834); cross-sectional prevalent myopia OR 0.964 (95% CI 0.945-0.982). Pooled trials show a reduced myopic shift of -0.30 D over 3 years (95% CI -0.18 to -0.41). The critical dissociation: when analysis is restricted to children who are ALREADY myopic, dose-response finds no relationship between time outdoors and myopic progression (R-squared = 0.00064). Outdoor time prevents onset; it does not treat established myopia.
Genetic confound
High for the cross-sectional and cohort strata pooled here - children who spend more time outdoors have parents and genotypes that differ from those who do not, and parental myopia is one of the strongest predictors of child myopia. The clinical-trial stratum is the only genuinely unconfounded estimate in the paper.

Effects

OutcomeMetricValueMeasureTimingVsHorizonClass
Incident myopia, clinical trials onlypooled risk ratio0.536 (95% CI 0.338 to 0.850)standardizedend of trial follow-upbusiness-as-usualend-of-treatmenthealth
Myopic shift in refractive error, trialsweighted mean difference (dioptres)-0.30 D (95% CI -0.18 to -0.41)standardized3 yearsbusiness-as-usualend-of-treatmenthealth
Myopia progression in already-myopic eyesdose-response R-squaredR-squared = 0.00064 - no relationship detectedstandardizedpoolednoneunclearhealth

Cited by