The Evidence on Teaching

Getting Parents Involved: A Field Experiment in Deprived Schools

Avvisati F, Gurgand M, Guyon N, Maurin E · 2014

grade Brctindependentunreplicated
Sample
large-scale controlled experiment across a French deprived educational district; randomisation at the class level within schools
Population
Parents of middle-school children in a deprived French educational district
Design
Randomised parent-school meeting programme, with the randomisation done in a way that also identifies peer spillovers at class level. Outcomes are administrative behaviour records and test scores rather than self-report.
Key findings
Treated families increased both school-based and home-based involvement — the intervention did what it set out to do. Pupils in treated classes showed better behaviour and attitudes, with truancy and disciplinary sanctions moving by roughly 15% of a standard deviation, and the effect was amplified by class-level peer interaction. TEST SCORES DID NOT IMPROVE. This is the cleanest available demonstration that raising parental involvement is achievable and cheap, moves conduct, and does not by itself move achievement.
Genetic confound
Low — randomised assignment of the programme, so parental traits are balanced across arms by construction.
Replication notes
Unreplicated as a design. The pattern — parent-directed interventions moving conduct and attendance while leaving achievement flat — recurs in the archive's attendance topic and in Bergman 2021's partial null on English.

Effects

OutcomeMetricValueMeasureTimingVsHorizonClass
Truancy and disciplinary sanctionsstandard deviationsaround 15% of an SD improvementstandardizedend of school yearbusiness-as-usualend-of-treatmentbehaviour
Test scoresstandard deviationsno improvementstandardizedend of school yearbusiness-as-usualend-of-treatmentdomain-skill
Parental involvement activities (the intervention's proximal target)directionincreased, both school-based and home-basedself-reportend of school yearbusiness-as-usualend-of-treatmentnon-cognitive

Cited by